Showing posts with label coaching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coaching. Show all posts

Monday

Notes for Conductors and Teachers

Few instruments seem as romantic and mysterious as a French horn. There are so many great sounds and great musical moments for horn but it is fraught with difficulty and danger.

We have the smallest mouthpiece, tubing almost as long as a tuba and a bell almost as large. We can blend with the flutes or blast over an entire orchestra. Good players have a five octave range, most of it usable.

Horn playing is like ice dancing on stilts while doing puzzles and lifting weights, while all the time someone is waving a stick at you trying to get you to dance in time with the music and the other players.

Check out Whip Your Brass Into Shape for notes on creating a good ensemble.

General rules that will help your horn players play their best
  • Do NOT have the horns sit in front of the tympani. Even if they don't complain. Many horn players are not even aware that this causes problems. The energy from the tympani goes right into the bell where it concentrates and focuses - right at the embouchure! If your horn section gets tired quickly and misses lots of notes try placing them or the tympani in an other location.
  • Do not ask your horn players to play the same high passages over and over. Even if they play them well you will be tiring them out.
  • Do not ask your horn players to play during your 'warm up' rehearsal right before a concert. How many youth symphonies get ready for playing a Tchaikovsky symphony by playing through the whole thing right before the concert! You are asking high school players to play a difficult, tiring piece of music twice! Your players will feel guilty not playing during your warm up rehearsal and will want to play every note. Don't let them! Do you want me to sound good before or during the concert?
  • Demand that your horn players count
  • Demand daily practice
  • Don't allow slouching or sloppy breathing
  • Don't teach from rote. Make them learn how to read! 

We believe every player must know how to conduct in order to play intelligently in an ensemble. Make sure they know the basic beat patterns and how prep beats work.

Teach them to hear perfect intervals and you will have a much better in tune ensembles. Perfect intervals have special qualities on a horn and the players will learn what they sound like if they are pointed out a few times. Read our article on intonation for help on tuning them.

Bands and orchestra go to great trouble to have all the principal woodwind and string players sit together but brass sections are frequently arranged in a straight line. Why? Your last French horn is now halfway across town from the tuba! Especially in younger groups it will help them greatly to sit as a section. Not only will they play more cleanly they will have more luck entering after a rest together.

About clams

No one wants the right notes to come out more than the player. No one. And as difficult as it is we are frequently put in a position that encourages clammy playing.

The factors you can't change come from the design and writing for horn. We miss more notes than any other instrument mostly because our open notes are so close together. For example on a Bb trumpet there is only one open note between third space C and the G at the top of the staff. On an F horn there are four. For some notes we can use as many as six different fingerings.

Other factors that make horn players clam are muscle fatigue (embouchure or ab muscles), intonation problems, sudden changes in the room air pressure or temperature and the intonation of the ensemble.

If a horn player walks into a room where people are warming up and are generally playing in tune it will be easy to play. You want to play an A 440? Someone in the room is probably already playing it or something in tune with it. But if you walk into a room where the intonation is all over the place you will be trying to play an A 440 when an A 443 and an A 438 are going into your bell, fighting your attempt to play.  Instead of the sounds going into your bell reinforcing the note you want to play, there will be sounds interfering with it.

Asking players to play too quietly or too loud will also cause clams. You have to be judicious. We have to fill the tube with enough air to keep a steady sound and not so much that we break it.

And try to have a friendly attitude towards your players. If they are truly trying you will not make it better by taking it personally.

Saturday

Contact Scott Hartman

For Mr. Hartman's biography check the Santa Clara University site
http://www.scu.edu/cas/music/facultyandstaff/scott_hartman.cfm

Mr. Hartman performs extensively throughout the Bay Area and Central Coast. He coaches school, youth and community symphony and professional brass sections throughout California.

Mr. Hartman teaches privately at his home in west San Jose.

For schedules, fees and travel rates please contact him via email or telephone.

Scott Hartman
Scottito@Pacbell.net
(408) 781-0019

Wednesday

How to Make the Right Sound - About Tone Color

How do I make the right sound?

How do I sound like the big symphony players I hear? 


Do I need special equipment? A huge body? Big lung capacity?
These are some of the most vexing problems in learning to play.

How do we know what sound to make when it is different to me than it is to the audience?

If you sit next to a horn player on stage and listen to them then move to the audience you will be amazed at how different it sounds. If you move around the hall it will sound different in every spot.

Then what sound is ‘right?’


What Influences Your Sound
  • Your body, throat and mouth
  • The mouthpiece
  • The leadpipe
  • The cylindrical section
  • The bell branch
  • Your right hand
  • Your clothes
  • The room
  • The listener’s ear and the listener’s brain

It’s affected by what other sounds are being made and the textures of the surfaces of the room.

So what does matter
  • The sound is clear and in tune.
  • Volume and pitch are generally brick shaped yet conform to the phrase
  • The air is being controlled from around and below the belly button
That’s about it.

Airy and fuzzy sounds don’t travel far so they shouldn’t worry you too much, as long as you are breathing correctly and the notes are shaped correctly.

Tone Color

A much more important concept for us to pay attention to is tone color.  Think of it as how bright and shiny or warm and dull your sound is.

It’s great to be able to change tone color while making music, but for these exercises try to keep a clear, bright tone color at all times.

In Exercise #1 the goal is to try to get all the notes to have the same tone color as the first note. If you play the three note pattern and the third note has a different tone color then something is changing that doesn’t need to change or that note is out of tune and that makes the color change. In any case it indicates that something is moving that doesn’t need to.

A great way to get a feel for breathing from Place #6 is to practice decrescendos without letting the tone color change. If the sound gets dark and dull as you get quiet then you are not doing it right. If you keep the tone bright and straight while decrescendoing.

What will make tone color change when doing the exercises
  • Shallow breathing, controlled from too high up
  • The air support sagging, especially at the end of notes
  • Excessive movement of the jaw
  • Movement in the tongue near the molars
  • Tension in the tongue or cheeks
It can be difficult to tell when we are playing. It helps to have another player listen to figure what might be causing a problem.

Being able to control your tone color is a huge part of Left Coast Horn Playing. We work on it every day.

In General

We are in no way saying that this is how you should always sound but for these drills it helps to keep a bright shiny sound because that’s when the air is used most efficiently.

These exercises are to gain strength, efficiency and control, not to define a playing style. That is separate.

It’s easy to hear a bad tone color. Almost always the root of the problem is controlling the breath too high, making it weak and wobbly.

Whip your Brass into Shape - The Brigade System

The system here is named after the work of August Escoffier, a French chef who created the brigade system for modern restaurant and hotel kitchens.  It is a simple system and it works. Players need to know when to lead and when to follow and this system allows them to learn and put it into play.

The Brigade System

The purpose of the System is to get all of the musicians focused on the task at hand while applying the techniques that create great music. It gives their minds direction when they would normally wander. It can be taught quickly. It is appropriate for middle school and older.

Players need to be taught how to play cleanly, balanced and in tune. They can only do this if they know who to match and whom to play cleanly, balanced and in tune with.

Section players balance and tune to the principal of the section

If the principal trumpet is playing then the other trumpet players listen to them and copy their dynamics, phrase shape, pitch, style, tone color, etc.

The other principals listen to the principal trumpet. The principals also need to know if they have the tune and should project above the orchestra, or if they should back off and have their section blend with the rest of the orchestra. Any player who has a solo line may ask the whole section to pipe down when they are playing.

If the principals can’t see the principal trumpet, then make them move. If the members of a section can’t see their principal make them move. Or course this not always possible during a full rehearsal but it is worth the effort if it is possible, and it should be done at all times during sectionals.

Active playing vs. passive playing

Make sure the players are playing actively.

Developing your section

When working with a brass section conduct as little as possible. Do not begin by counting out loud. I have the section leader simply take a breath in tempo then play. There will be resistance at first but you will find the section will learn to do this easily and it greatly improves ensemble. Have them practice starting without a conductor. Have them do it until it is really together a few times in a row. Five minutes of focus on this will make them a far better ensemble.

Stop frequently and ask questions

If you stop frequently and ask, ‘who has the lead line’ or ‘how is the balance right now between the trombones and trumpets’ you are going to make the players think and work to get it right. If you wait until the end of the piece you are giving permission for the players to be passive while playing it through. If you stop and demand that they pay attention then their minds will be driven to pay attention and they will pay attention while they play the whole piece.

Demand that they learn to read music

So much music is taught by rote these days. Christmas music is passed out in September.  End of the school year music is passed out in January. Youth symphonies give out their year’s worth of music during the summer but don’t hold the players accountable for knowing it at the first rehearsal.  Many students learn to play by copying the person next to them.

There are high school brass sections where the average experience is 4 or 5 years but players don’t know the names of notes or the fingerings. One student who had piano lessons for 8 years and played in school bands for 4 years when he started taking lesson  did not know what a key signature was,  the note names or what kind of rests there were. When asked how his piano teacher put up with it and he said she just showed him where to put his fingers on the keys and how to play. Hopefully they weren’t paying much for those lessons.

If you are too busy to instruct individuals, give them written assignments or send them to good teachers. If they are not fluent in reading music, your section will only sound good with many rote rehearsals.

Everyone must know how to conduct

If your players don’t know what beat pattern is being used how can they start and stop cleanly?

1) Have them practice a prep beat with the other players playing. Do it on a regular basis until they are all breathing and starting together cleanly.

2) Teach them 2.4 first, then 3/4 then 4/4.

Teach them to count

They must be held accountable for not counting or subdividing or miscounting rests. Players need to be given the tools to  learn. Teach them to count on their fingers, or use verbal games or whatever tools you use. But be insistent that they apply them and be responsible. 

Young brass players have trouble counting long rests. It’s difficult for them to focus on something so simple. Add the negative feedback when they don’t enter properly and they are set up to fail. Instead of being negative demand that they use a system. If they fail to come in, go back and play the same section and make them practice counting the rests. Don’t give them cues to listen for unless it’s in addition to making them count.

When to be positive, when to be negative

The brass player’s experience is often one of neglect except when problems arise. In an orchestra the brass may only get comments from the conductor when they fail to enter or miss notes.  You have to teach them how to count long rests and to subdivide, then you must demand that they do both. You also must recognize when they are doing a good job and congratulate them frequently.

Some leaders scream and cajole. That’s ok as long as there are instructions. If they are not trying then I give you license to chastise harshly. But most of the time when leaders yell at their kids the kids do not have the tools to do what the leader wants.

Being demanding does not mean yelling or berating them. Simply demand that they do what you have taught them. Many leaders ask the group to do something then gives up after one try.  Two minutes of boredom fixing an issue is nothing compared with a lifetime of good playing. The more you demand of kids the more they will succeed and will appreciate the success.

How you can help them play their best

• Make sure your players are warmed up before rehearsal. One of the biggest differences between amateur and professional groups is what happens 15 minutes before rehearsal. Amateurs sit around and talk. Pros warm up seriously and take some last minute shots at the tricky parts.

Don’t have them play a warm up rehearsal. Why would you do that to them? I have seen youth symphonies warm up by playing through entire Shostakovitch symphonies. Come on! The same conductor who did this called me later to ask why the brass was screechy at the end.

Professional orchestras usually have rules written into the contract describing how soon before a concert you can have a rehearsal. It’s to insure a good concert. Do the same for your students! If you are nervous about them all being there or want to go over a couple of places in the music it can be constructive but if they haven’t learned the music by the day of the concert what good are you doing by running through the whole thing?

• Don’t line up your brass section all across the back of the orchestra. They should be in a section, like woodwinds and strings. They will be more likely to play together and to come in correctly if they are seated in a section. 

• It is critical that the players be taught to recognize perfect intervals and how to tune them. Without strong intonation across the group the section will sound thin, the players will tire quickly and the soloists will miss more notes.  Perfect intervals on brass instruments have magical qualities when done right, grating qualities when done poorly.

• Some people feel strongly that you must tune to the lowest voice in the section (mainly tuba players!) but this is rarely how it works in the professional world. In the pro world if you are playing second and turn to the first player and say ‘you are out of tune and need to follow me’ there is a chance you will get fired or not called back.

In a community, school or youth orchestra setting, do you really want your sections to tune to the weakest player?

Demand that they act professionally

Demand that they be on time. For performances they should look sharp. It’s show biz! A loose atmosphere is fine and we brass players like to joke around but there’s a difference between a loose atmosphere and sloppy standards.

Shined shoes, clean shirts and combed hair are part of our professional deportment. Teach it to your players at a young age and they will feel professional when they play.

Your Players Need to Know This

Imagine a sports team where every player knows exactly what they are supposed to do but they don’t know what anyone else is going to do.

Chaos, right? Quarterbacks and receivers on different routes, shortstops throwing to bases that aren't covered and goalies not paying attention during corner kicks - it's the same as an oboist playing staccato while hornists play legato, or a conductor beating Beethoven's 5th in 5!

What if the players don't know what play the coaches want to run? That’s an orchestra where the players don’t have ensemble skills.

A famous player once said, I have been asked to give a lecture on intonation. Here is my lecture: those who know how to play in tune adjust to those who don’t.

This tells a lot about this player and the world famous ensemble in which he plays principal. Primarily it says that they do not have a leader, policy, practice or culture that tells them how to play in tune.  What system are they using? What exactly does that mean?

Those of you who are now thinking the musicians have to know 'how to play in tune' or they are unqualified to play in that group are missing the point. Sure they know about it and generally what it means. Some of them will be able to talk in terms of cents difference and different intonation schemes. Some will have differing opinions of what it means or how to apply it.  Many players just hope they sound OK and never think about it.

Can you imagine a sports coach telling his players that whatever their theory is is OK with the coach?

Some sections tune from the bottom up and some tune from the top down. Both ways can produce fantastic results - but only if everyone in the section knows which way you are tuning.

Players in an ensemble should know
  • Whether they are playing texture, rhythm or the lead at all times
  • Who is playing texture, rhythm or lead at all times
  • Who is listening to you
  • Whom to copy (volume, style, etc)What a conductor does (patterns, prep beats, etc)
  • How to tune and balance
  • What style of music you are playing and how they need to play to express that style
Left Coast musicians advocate the Brigade System.  It takes minutes to teach and has lasting constructive effects!

If you are leading the ensemble and the players don’t know these things the ensemble is not going to perform at their highest ability. Spend the time to train them! Demand that they get it right!

Slow to Fast Practice - a Powerful Technique

Slow to Fast is a learning technique that helps us acquire new skills quickly. It helps to make patterns or skills repeatable.

Use this technique to
  • Teach our brains to remember skills we want to last a long time
  • Learn complicated skills quickly and reliably
When we learn a new skill our brains aren’t sure if it should be stored where it keeps important memories like how to walk, or things it needed once a long time ago like getting off a chair you sat in once a year ago. The Slow to Fast technique described below signals the brain to move it where you can get it quickly.
If you want to learn something and have it be part of your permanent skill set this helps greatly. It works great for scales and trills and all sorts of exercises or complicated passages.

If you ever get called at the last minute to sight read a concert you will appreciate this technique. When I get to the hall I look for complicated rhythms or technical passages, I do them slow to fast once or twice and I am almost always ready to play them in the show.

If you want to learn a long complicated passage, learn bits of it and then string them together. For example if you have a long passage of scales that are hard to play, start by playing just the first measure Slow to Fast. When you can play it comfortably add the next measure. Keep going until you have mastered the passage.

Some people like to learn the end of a passage and work backwards.

To practice Slow to Fast
  • Play the bit very slowly. Start painfully like ‘when are you going to play the next note?’ slowly.
  • Keep repeating it gradually increasing the speed.
  • If something goes wrong then play then next time play it slower. It is more important to get it right than to just get through it.
  • Continue accelerating until you can’t get it to go any faster.  Then go faster. You always want to drive PAST the point where it doesn’t work any more.  At the end it should be falling apart. If it still sounds good then go faster!
  • Then relax for a second, take the biggest breath you possibly can and play the passage as many times as you can in that breath.
That’s it. A very quick and powerful technique! Use it every day and your improvement will skyrocket!

How to Play Left Coast Exercises

Left Coast exercises are meant to be concentrated and leveraged. They are short so we can really focus on what we are trying to accomplish. They are designed to be flexible and extensible.

Always play them with a steady rhythm and start slowly!

In all the exercises have these goals in mind

If you don’t take a deep low breath, controlling the air from Place #6 then none of this matters. While playing these exercises always take a deep, relaxed breath, controlling the air from as low in your body as possible.

When the exercises advise you to keep the same tone color throughout, we are looking for brightness. Some of our exercises ask you to decrescendo without changing tone color. You can only do this if you control the air from below Place #5, halfway between your rib cage and your belly button.

We use these decrescendo exercises not only to learn to make beautiful decrescendos and control the ends of the notes but to train ourselves to control the air from as low as possible.

Some of our exercises have sffz on them. These are to be played loudly and with as much air as is possible to push through the horn. Play them loud all the way through with no decrescendo or softening at all. Be tasteless and wild! If your neighbors call the police you are doing it right!

If the exercise says to play Slow to Fast, then start really really slow. The slower the better. You can increase the tempo right away but start out really slowly.

For Slow to Fast exercises go faster and faster until you reach the point it falls apart. Never play as fast as you can then quit. Go faster! Always push!

In all technical exercises every day try to go higher, lower, faster, slower, louder, quieter! Always push yourself!

While these exercises can be done occasionally you will improve very fast if you do them every day. Ten minutes a day doing these drills will help you improve much faster than doing them for once for an hour each week.

Riddle

What’s this?
  • Right ear 
  • Heart, soul, intellect and ears
  • Left ear
  • Left ear
  • Left ear
It’s a horn section!
  • The assistant uses his right ear to listen to the principal
  • The principal uses all his experience, talent, soul and technique they can while listening to the other principals
  • The second horn listens to the principal
  • The third horn listens to the second horn or the principal
  • The fourth horn listens to the third horn or the principal

Playing as a section is more important than your differences
Each position has unique responsibilities.
 

Of course these are general rules and exaggerations. If the second horn has a solo then everyone else should listen to them, etc. And there are other ways to organize things. But this is how it is done in Left Coast playing.

Few things ruin the sound of a horn section like a player who refuses to match the players in the section. 
 
Sections that play very well together know that being together and in tune with your section is more important than being in tune with other sections or players in the ensemble.

Active vs. Passive Playing

Learn to play together!
Are you an active musician or a passive one? Do you actively listen, count, think about your air or do you simply hope what comes out of your bell is fine?

Active players know their role in an ensemble and pay attention to filling that role.

Horn playing is so complex we have to count, listen, imagine and think about love, money and politics or whatever is on your mind at the same time. Fortunately our brains can handle it.

Indications you are an active player
  • You think about the music before you play it
  • You understand what a conductor does and are actively trying to fit in to it
  • You listen carefully to the principal of your section, or if you are principal you listen to the other principals and you play in a way that helps your section follow you
  • If something you play doesn’t sound good or you have trouble producing it you figure out why and work on it. Even if you don’t know why you work on it
  • You count and subdivide and know where you are in the music at all times

To become an active player
  • Practice playing and counting until it becomes second nature. Know what beat and what fraction of a beat you are playing at all times!
  • Know how to conduct simple beat patterns and know how to do a preparation beat
  • Listen listen listen! Listen to recordings, listen to your teachers and most of all listen to the people you are playing with

Wise leaders encourage active playing
  • Instead of teaching by rote they insist that students sight read frequently
  • They make sure that each player is taking the time to learn their individual parts
  • They make sure the players know what the basic beat patterns are and know the basics of conducting
  • They teach ensemble skills and insist the players learn them

Most sectional rehearsals as used to teach players the notes rather than on playing as a section. Pity.

If you are leading a rehearsal and you start off ‘one two three four’ then all the players will be passive unless they are counting with you and feeling your beat as you count - which they won't be doing. Counting out loud for them induces them to be passive.

Never sing a part to teach rhythm or pitch. Let them figure it out. Don't spoon feed! You can sing if you are demonstrating a style or technique but not to teach rhythm or pitch.

Sectional rehearsals should be done as much as possible without a conductor.  If you want to teach a section to play together they have to pay attention to each other, not the conductor. If you tell the ensemble that someone is too loud they will fix that particular problem but they won’t learn how to depend on themselves to play balanced.
Teach your principal player to start the section off by taking a breath for one beat before the music starts, just like a conductor gives a preparation beat. Have them practice starting together.

Encourage the section to play this way in the larger ensemble too. It's the only way to play together as a section!

When you tell them to fix a problem you are active and they are passive. If you tell them there is a problem then let them fix it, then they become active.